Archaeologists have unearthed the earliest, darkest history of America's second-oldest college.

Archaeologists have unearthed the earliest, darkest history of America's second-oldest college.


July 17, 2025 | Jack Hawkins

Archaeologists have unearthed the earliest, darkest history of America's second-oldest college.


A Campus Built On Secrets

William & Mary College, chartered in 1693, holds the title of America's second-oldest college. Its historic campus in Williamsburg, Virginia, has long been a symbol of colonial academic tradition. But beneath the ivy-covered bricks lies a deeper story. Recent discoveries are challenging the known timeline and illuminating centuries of layered history.

Rss Thumb - William & Mary College

Advertisement

The Wren Building’s Not-So-Humble Beginnings

The Sir Christopher Wren Building is a crown jewel of the college, constructed at the turn of the 18th century. Long believed to be the oldest edifice on campus, it's now clear that the story began even earlier. Nearby digs have uncovered a brick kiln site that predates the Wren Building, suggesting that the foundational work for the college started years before official records indicate.

File:ChristopherWrenBuilding.jpgMiguelYerena, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Reuncovering The Forgotten Kiln

Originally found in the 1930s, the colonial-era brick kiln was documented but quickly reburied. For decades, it remained hidden beneath manicured campus lawns. Thanks to new preservation initiatives, archaeologists reopened the site, confirming its role in producing bricks for the earliest campus buildings. This discovery reframes what we thought we knew about the college’s origin story.

File:Wren 1859 william and mary.jpgBkwillwm, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

The Bray School Rises From The Earth

Among the most remarkable finds is the foundation of the Williamsburg Bray School. Founded in 1760, this school for free and enslaved Black children was operated with a revolutionary goal for its time—educating young minds regardless of status. Its rediscovery on campus is a profound reminder of forgotten chapters in American education.

File:Williamsburg Bray School building in October 2021 4.jpgSer Amantio di Nicolao, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

A Secret Cellar Beneath The Books

Archaeologists uncovered something unexpected beneath the Bray School’s long-lost foundation: a hidden cellar. Never documented in college records, this space held artifacts dating from the 1700s to the 1900s. It paints a picture of a building that evolved in use and meaning over centuries.

A Secret Cellar Beneath The BooksArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

Treasures In The Dirt

The Bray School featured many personal effects buried in the soil. Pencils, pens, buttons, small toys, all belonged to the children who attended the school, each artifact telling a story of who they might have been—and what horrors their little eyes might have witnessed.

Treasures In The DirtArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

Colonoware & Culture Clash

One especially significant find: colonoware pottery. There isn't much of the handmade pottery linked to enslaved persons left, but its discovery at William & Mary College tells us of the earliest roots of enslavement in the United States.

Colonoware & Culture ClashArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

Minerva’s Glimmering Wisdom

Archaeologists found a piece of glass bearing the image of Minerva, the Roman goddess of wisdom. It's a fitting part of the school's history, as it has long been associated with teaching those deemed unworthy by the rest of society.

Minerva’s Glimmering WisdomArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

A Building That Wore Many Hats

The Bray School was one of the earliest educational institutions for African-Americans in the U.S., founded in 1760 for free and enslaved African-American children. It has a dark history of oppression, "re-education," and brutality. When it finally closed, the building became a Methodist convent.

File:Williamsburg Bray School building in October 2021.jpgSer Amantio di Nicolao, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

History on the Move

Using tree-ring dating, experts could date the building back to 1760, which sparked a massive effort to relocate and preserve it. In 2023, the structure was moved to Colonial Williamsburg, and two years later, it opened to the public.

File:Williamsburg Bray School move 1.jpgPbritti, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Gates Hall Opens the Next Chapter

While renovating Gates Hall, crews unearthed even more of the Bray School’s remains, including its original brick foundation and parts of the hidden cellar. These revelations have expanded the understanding of the school's physical footprint and prompted additional archaeological attention to other nearby campus sites.

Gates Hall Opens the Next ChapterArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

Layers of Time, One Shovel at a Time

The artifacts discovered span multiple centuries, representing not just the Bray School era, but the subsequent chapters of the building’s life. Each layer unearthed by archaeologists adds new context to the intertwined histories of the college, the town, and the students once overlooked by mainstream narratives.

Layers of Time, One Shovel at a TimeArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

A Community-Centered Approach

Recognizing the importance of inclusivity, William & Mary College is working closely with the Williamsburg Bray School Descendant Community. The goal is to co-curate the historical record and exhibit materials in a way that honors those with ancestral ties to the school—putting people, not just artifacts, at the center of the story.

A Community-Centered ApproachArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

Education In The Exhibit Hall

The recovered artifacts will be housed in Gates Hall and featured in the upcoming Colin G. and Nancy N. Campbell Archaeology Center. These spaces aim to bring history alive for students and visitors alike, transforming the college campus into a living classroom.

File:Colin G. Calloway 8315655.jpgSlowking4, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Building A Future Through The Past

These discoveries are more than relics. They provide an avenue for difficult conversations about race, education, and memory. William & Mary is using the past to guide institutional reflection, acknowledging its participation in systems of enslavement and segregation while charting a more inclusive future.

Building A Future Through The PastJrcla2, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Shovels As Storytellers

This wave of archaeology highlights how physical evidence can tell stories long excluded from textbooks. Inscriptions fade and oral histories fragment, but bricks and buttons endure. Archaeology has become a critical tool in recovering marginalized histories.

Archaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation Archaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

A Quiet Strength Endures

The legacy of the Bray School speaks to the power of education in the face of oppression. That such a school existed at all in the colonial South is a testament to the hopes and determination of enslaved families and their allies. Its rediscovery invites reflection on the enduring struggle for educational equity.

File:Williamsburg Bray School building in October 2021 5.jpgSer Amantio di Nicolao, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Digging Is Just The Beginning

While much has been found, the work isn’t over. Excavations continue across the William & Mary campus, each spadeful of earth offering the potential to rewrite history. Researchers expect to find additional structures, artifacts, and perhaps even documents that connect past and present.

Digging Is Just The BeginningArchaeologists Uncover Williamsburg Bray School Foundation | William & Mary, William & Mary

Advertisement

You May Also Like:

Oceanographers Have Uncovered New Evidence That Completely Changes Our Understanding Of The Bermuda Triangle

Free Disneyland Perks You're Probably Walking Right Past

Overrated American Tourist Traps That Locals Avoid 

Sources: 1, 2, 3


READ MORE

Top Three Hotels For Adventurers

If you’re looking for unique thrills, an average hotel just won’t cut it. For an unforgettable vacation, check out one of these amazing adventure hotels.
June 13, 2023 Kaddy Gibson
Gros Morne National Park

Five Incredible Destinations For Nature Lovers

If you’re looking to embrace the call of the wild and experience breathtaking views, check out these great nature destinations.
June 13, 2023 Kaddy Gibson
St. George's Church

The Creepiest Abandoned Attractions

Despite their ominous origins, these abandoned attractions have become some of the world’s most popular tourist destinations.
June 13, 2023 Kaddy Gibson
internal-louvre

Destination Of The Day: Paris

With rich history, beautiful streets, and world-renowned cuisine, it’s no wonder why Paris is among the top tourist destinations.
June 14, 2023 Kaddy Gibson
internal-vienna

Destination Of The Day: Vienna

With an abundance of beautiful architecture, fine art, and historical attractions it's easy to see why Vienna was once considered the capital of the world.
June 14, 2023 Kaddy Gibson
bali_internal

Destination Of The Day: Bali

Bali is one of the most popular tourist destinations in the world, but don’t let that stop you from visiting this beautiful Indonesian island.
June 14, 2023 Kaddy Gibson