American "Secret Spots" That Locals Won't Talk About (And Tourists Shouldn't Ask)

American "Secret Spots" That Locals Won't Talk About (And Tourists Shouldn't Ask)


September 30, 2025 | Peter Kinney

American "Secret Spots" That Locals Won't Talk About (And Tourists Shouldn't Ask)


Untold Tales

You walk past towns and landmarks every day, yet residents know things outsiders don’t. Hushed memories, old scars, and unspoken rules give these places an invisible layer, perhaps even a few lingering legends.

Area 51

Advertisement

Salem, Massachusetts

The witch trial hysteria that consumed Salem between 1692–1693 remains America's most infamous case of mass persecution, yet locals tackle the topic with the delicacy of someone defusing an explosive. Apparently, two young girls experienced "fits" in Reverend Samuel Parris's household.

File:HouseWhereWitchcraftStarted.pngHenrietta D. Kimball, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Salem, Massachusetts (Cont.)

This tale has spiraled into accusations against 200 people, resulting in 19 executions by hanging, one by crushing, and at least five demises in prison. Shame over the witch trials ran so deep that it took around 300 years before a memorial to the victims was set up.

File:Salem witch2.jpgJoseph E., ca. 1837-1914, artist., Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Centralia, Pennsylvania

On May 27, 1962, Centralia's volunteer fire department attempted its annual Memorial Day cleanup by burning trash in an abandoned mine, never imagining they'd ignite an underground inferno that's still burning 60 years later. The state spent $7 million between 1962 and 1982 trying to extinguish the flames.

File:Old Mine Fire 1969.jpgU.S. Bureau of Mines., Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Centralia, Pennsylvania (Cont.)

They dug trenches, sealed openings, pumped in crushed rock—but nothing worked. Today, the fire burns across 3,700 acres at depths up to 300 feet and could continue. Pennsylvania invoked eminent domain in 1992, condemning all buildings and revoking the town's ZIP code in 2002. 

File:Centralia smoke rising.jpgThe original uploader was Jrmski at English Wikipedia., Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Mount Rushmore, South Dakota

What millions see as a patriotic shrine to American democracy, the Lakota Sioux know as the desecration of Tunkasila Sakpe Paha—Six Grandfathers Mountain—their most sacred site. The irony cuts deep as this monument celebrates presidents on land stolen directly in violation of the 1868 Treaty of Fort Laramie.

File:Mount Rushmore - 51107298113.jpgEric Friedebach, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Mount Rushmore, South Dakota (Cont.)

It had promised the Black Hills to the Lakota “in perpetuity”.That perpetuity lasted only until 1874, when General George Armstrong Custer's expedition discovered gold, triggering a rush that the government used as justification to seize the sacred Black Hills.

File:GenGACuster.jpgCivil War glass negative collection (Library of Congress), Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Camp Hero, Montauk, New York

Netflix's Stranger Things was originally titled Montauk for good reason. Camp Hero State Park sits at the tip of Long Island like a forgotten chapter from a science fiction novel. This innocent former military base has spawned decades of whispered conspiracies about mind control experiments.

File:At Long Island 2023 121.jpgPhotograph by Mike Peel (www.mikepeel.net)., Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Camp Hero, Montauk, New York (Cont.)

Residents maintain an uneasy relationship with the Montauk Project legends that refuse to die, particularly since Preston Nichols' 1992 book claimed he recovered suppressed memories of working at the facility. While officials insist the base simply housed radar equipment, explorers have spotted eerie graffiti reading "Stranger Help Me".

File:Montauk1.jpgUser:Americasroof at English Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Portlock, Alaska

Portlock is an abandoned ghost town located on the southern edge of the Kenai Peninsula. It was initially established as a cannery community in the early 20th century and named after British Captain Nathaniel Portlock, who explored the area in the late 18th century. 

File:Portlock.jpgBritish School, c. 1788, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Portlock, Alaska (Cont.)

This region was mainly inhabited by Russian-Aleut people and had a post office by 1921. According to legends from nearby communities, a mysterious creature called Nantinaq, sometimes described as a forest spirit or Bigfoot-like humanoid, was believed to have stalked and struck residents.

File:Patterson Gimlin Bigfoot.jpgRoger Patterson and Robert Gimlin, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dulce Base, New Mexico

The small town of fewer than 3,000 residents has become a pilgrimage site for conspiracy theorists convinced that a seven-story joint human-alien facility operates beneath Archuleta Mesa. While the town's Jicarilla Apache leaders have accepted UFO tourism, many folks remain deeply uncomfortable with the attention. 

File:Dulce Lake, Jacarilla Apache Nation, New Mexico, USA.jpgChristopher Nicol, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dulce Base, New Mexico (Cont.)

Paul Bennewitz contended in the 1970s and 1980s that he intercepted signals/electronic communications. The legend gained credibility when multiple "whistleblowers" came forward claiming to have worked at the facility, including engineer Phil Schneider, who alleged he survived an underground battle between humans and aliens in 1979. 

Residents of Dulce claim UFOs, Bigfoot spotted in area by KOATResidents of Dulce claim UFOs, Bigfoot spotted in area by KOAT

Advertisement

North Brother Island, New York

Between Manhattan and the Bronx sits a 13-acre island that most New Yorkers pretend doesn't exist, despite being visible from several popular waterfront areas. North Brother Island is said to be the final resting place of "Typhoid Mary" Mallon, who spent decades quarantined there.

File:Typhoid Mary full.jpgUnknown artistUnknown artist, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

North Brother Island, New York (Cont.)

The island also witnessed the worst maritime disaster in New York City history when the passenger steamship General Slocum caught fire nearby in 1904, killing over 1,000 people. Today, the island remains completely off-limits to the public due to unstable structures.

File:General slocum burning.jpgUnknown photographer, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Sharpsburg, Maryland

This peaceful locality of 700 residents experiences an annual invasion of Civil War enthusiasts every September. However, the Battle of Antietam, fought in and around Sharpsburg, remains the single worst day in American history, with over 22,000 casualties in just 12 hours of fighting.

File:Main Street in Sharpsburg, Maryland, 1862.jpgAlexander Gardner (1821-1882), Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Sharpsburg, Maryland (Cont.)

Walking through modern Sharpsburg means navigating streets where neighbors still find musket balls in their gardens and human remains occasionally surface during construction projects. The psychological weight of living atop what amounts to a massive burial ground affects residents in ways that outsiders struggle to comprehend.

File:Antietam National Battlefield - Sharpsburg, Maryland (6262941851).jpgDoug Kerr from Albany, NY, United States, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Glen Cove (Sogorea Te), California

What appears to be a serene 15-acre park overlooking the Carquinez Strait represents one of the Bay Area's most contentious sacred site battles. During the 109-day occupation in 2011, Native American activists established a holy fire to prevent the city from building restrooms directly over ancestor remains. 

File:Protesters at Sogorea Te (Glen Cove).jpgdignidadrebelde's photostream, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Glen Cove (Sogorea Te), California (Cont.)

While the cultural easement signed after the standoff technically protects the site, folks remain divided between those who support Indigenous rights and others who resent the restrictions on development, creating an atmosphere where casual mentions of Glen Cove can quickly escalate into heated debates.

File:Sogorea Te.jpgdignidadrebelde's photostream, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Area 51, Nevada

Deep in the Nevada desert sits a military base so classified that for years, the government refused to acknowledge it existed at all. The CIA only admitted Area 51 was real in 2013, despite operating since 1955 as a testing ground for experimental aircraft.

File:Area 51 Main Gate.jpgDavid James Henry, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Area 51, Nevada (Cont.)

Forget the alien conspiracy theories; it's the very real federal agents who monitor conversations, the camouflaged sensors scattered throughout the desert, and the knowledge that even mentioning employment at nearby contractor facilities can trigger background investigations. Workers sign NDAs so comprehensive that violating them means potential treason charges.

File:Wfm x51 area51 warningsign.jpgX51, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dudleytown, Connecticut

The abandoned settlement sits in the Dark Entry Forest, where visitors report an unnatural silence—no birds, no insects, just extreme silence among the skeletal remains of stone foundations. Local families who lived there in the 1700s and 1800s experienced an unusual pattern of madness.

File:GuilfordCT DudleytownHD 1.jpgMagicpiano, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Dudleytown, Connecticut (Cont.)

Even skeptical residents admit the forest has an oppressive atmosphere, and the Dark Entry Forest Association keeps it completely closed to prevent the constant stream of paranormal investigators who claim to encounter shadow figures, unexplained sounds, and an overwhelming sense of dread that lingers long after they leave.

File:GuilfordCT DudleytownHD 2.jpgMagicpiano, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Helltown, Ohio

Helltown is an area in northern Summit County, originally known as Boston Township. It has a complex history dating back to early 19th-century settlers who developed it as a farming and mill town. The name "Helltown" is associated with local legends and its rough reputation due to its isolated location.

File:Interstate 80 over the Cuyahoga River.jpgNyttend, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

Helltown, Ohio (Cont.)

In the 1970s, the US government used eminent domain to acquire a significant portion of the land in Boston Township to establish part of the Cuyahoga Valley National Park. This action led to the evacuation of residents and abandonment of the area.

File:Cuyahoga Valley National Park 20.jpgNiagara66, Wikimedia Commons

Advertisement

READ MORE

Ranking The Highest And Lowest Income States—According To Data

According to the latest data from the US Census Bureau, the median household income (MHI) in the United States in 2023 was, $77,719. Which begs the question: Where do the MHIs of each state rank—and which ones fall above and below the American average?
January 29, 2025 Jesse Singer
DB Cooper

The Most Intriguing Cases Of People Who Vanished Without A Trace

What happens when someone vanishes into thin air? Throughout history, certain disappearances have captivated the public imagination because of their mysterious circumstances and the lingering questions they leave behind.
January 30, 2025 Peter Kinney
Pamukkale

The Bizarre Wonders Of Pamukkale, Turkey's "Cotton Palace"

Learn all about Pamukkale, Turkey, where the travertine terraces meet ancient ruins in a breathtaking mix of nature and history. Explore the cotton castle's natural wonders, immerse yourself in the ancient city of Hierapolis, and savor the vibrant Turkish culture.
January 11, 2024 Kaddy Gibson
The Truth About The Curse Of King Tut's Tomb

The Truth About The Curse Of King Tut's Tomb

The curse of King Tut's tomb is a fascinating story...but is there really any truth behind it?
January 25, 2024 Samantha Henman